A practical guide for California contractors with crews, payroll and subcontractors.
A workers’ comp audit notice is routine. It doesn’t mean you’ve done something wrong or that an injury claim is being investigated.
When the notice arrives, confirm the policy period, response deadline, audit type and how to submit your records. Then organize the payroll, tax and subcontractor information the auditor requests.
The one thing you shouldn’t do is ignore it. Failing to cooperate with a workers’ compensation audit can lead to additional premium charges and, under certain circumstances, cancellation of your insurance coverage.
Here’s what California contractors need to know.
Why Am I Getting a Workers’ Comp Audit?
Your workers’ compensation premium was initially calculated using estimates.
Those estimates typically include your expected payroll, the work your employees perform and how that work is classified.
The audit compares those estimates with what actually happened during the policy period.
For contractors, plenty can change during a year. You might hire additional employees, increase wages, take on different projects or use subcontractors.
The audit allows the insurance company to calculate the final premium using the applicable audited exposure.
An audit doesn’t automatically mean you’ll owe additional money.
Depending on the results, you could owe additional premium, receive a return premium or see little change.
And if you cancelled your policy or switched insurance companies, you may still need to complete the audit for the expired policy.
What Should You Check When a Workers’ Comp Audit Notice Arrives?
Before gathering documents, read the notice carefully.
Six things matter.
1. The policy period
Confirm the beginning and ending dates of the policy being audited.
Workers’ compensation policies don’t necessarily follow the calendar year. If your policy ran from May to May, the auditor needs records covering that period—not simply your most recent calendar-year totals.
2. The response deadline
Identify when you must respond or provide records.
Treat that date seriously. If you need additional time, contact the auditor before the deadline and request written confirmation of any extension.
3. The audit type
Determine whether you’re being asked to complete a self-report, provide records for review, participate in a remote audit or arrange an on-site appointment.
These aren’t necessarily interchangeable, as we’ll explain below.
4. The document list
Review exactly what the auditor requested.
General audit checklists are useful, but the specific request from your insurer or auditor should guide what you prepare.
5. The submission method
Confirm whether records should be uploaded through a secure portal, delivered through another approved method or made available during an appointment.
6. Who is requesting the information
Insurance companies frequently use outside audit firms, so the auditor’s name may differ from the insurance company’s name.
That’s not necessarily a problem.
However, verify the request through your insurer or insurance broker before sending sensitive payroll or employee information.
Physical, Voluntary or Remote: What Kind of Workers’ Comp Audit Is This?
This is an area where contractors can get confused.
The type of audit describes what is reviewed. Remote describes how the audit is conducted.
They aren’t the same thing.
Physical audit
In California workers’ compensation terminology, a physical audit generally involves an auditor examining the employer’s original payroll records rather than relying only on a statement prepared by the employer.
Despite the name, a physical audit doesn’t always require an in-person meeting.
An auditor may examine the underlying records remotely.
Voluntary audit
A voluntary audit generally involves the employer reporting payroll and other requested information on an audit statement without the same examination of underlying records required for a physical audit.
Not every policy qualifies for this approach.
When is a physical audit required in California?
California’s Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) establishes physical audit requirements under the Uniform Statistical Reporting Plan.
Under the applicable rules:
- Policies producing a final premium of $10,500 or more generally require a physical audit at least annually, with the final audit covering the complete policy period.
- Policies below that threshold are subject to physical audits at intervals sufficient to ensure proper payroll reporting, with voluntary audits when a physical audit is not conducted.
- A policy below $10,500 that includes payroll in certain dual-wage construction classifications is also subject to a physical audit requirement, with a limited exception for qualifying renewals where one of the two preceding policy periods was physically audited.
These requirements are based on the applicable rules and policy circumstances. Your insurer determines the audit method required for your policy.
Special rules for California roofing contractors
California contractors holding a C-39 roofing license have additional requirements.
Under WCIRB rules, policies covering C-39 roofing contractors require a physical audit covering the complete policy period, regardless of premium size.
Separately, California Insurance Code §11665 requires an annual payroll audit that includes an in-person visit to the contractor’s place of business to verify the number of employees.
The insurer may impose a surcharge to recover the reasonable cost of the required audits.
These are two distinct requirements: examination of original records and the statutory in-person employee-count verification.
The takeaway: Don’t assume that an audit conducted remotely is merely a voluntary self-report. You may still need to provide detailed original records.
What Records Should You Have Ready?
The auditor’s request list controls what you need to provide.
For California contractors, commonly requested information includes:
- ☐ Payroll registers by employee covering the policy period.
- ☐ Federal Form 941 quarterly payroll tax returns.
- ☐ California DE 9 and DE 9C quarterly reports.
- ☐ Payroll by applicable workers’ compensation classification.
- ☐ Original time records supporting permitted divisions of payroll.
- ☐ Overtime records showing straight-time earnings and overtime premiums separately.
- ☐ Wage records for employees in applicable dual-wage construction classifications.
- ☐ Subcontractor names, work performed, payment amounts, contracts and invoices.
- ☐ Subcontractor workers’ compensation insurance records covering relevant work dates.
- ☐ Owner and officer information, including applicable coverage elections or waivers.
- ☐ Your CSLB license information.
- ☐ A description of the work your employees actually perform.
Not every auditor will request every item, and some contractors will need additional documentation.
Four areas deserve particular attention: employee classifications, time records, dual-wage classifications and subcontractors.
These can materially affect how the insurer calculates premium.
Don’t create or reconstruct records from memory to make the numbers fit. Locate the original supporting documents and identify any information that’s missing.
For more information about common recordkeeping problems, read our Resource Center article, Payroll Audits: What Contractors Get Wrong.
You can also explore our guides to California dual-wage classifications and subcontractor insurance verification.
What Happens During the Workers’ Comp Audit?
The auditor reviews your records and may ask questions about how your business operates.
For contractors, this matters because workers’ compensation classifications depend on the work being performed—not simply an employee’s job title.
An auditor may ask about your crews, projects, duties, payroll practices and subcontractor relationships.
Here are five practical steps.
Have the right person available
The person speaking with the auditor should understand your operations and payroll records.
Sometimes that’s the owner. Sometimes it’s the office manager, bookkeeper or payroll administrator.
If one person understands the field operations and another handles payroll, consider having both available.
Describe the actual work
Don’t rely on job titles alone.
A title such as “foreman,” “supervisor” or “project manager” doesn’t necessarily explain what someone does throughout the workday.
Describe the employee’s actual responsibilities and provide supporting records when requested.
Don’t guess
If you’re unsure about a question, tell the auditor you’ll verify the information and follow up.
An accurate answer supported by records is better than an estimate made during a phone call.
Keep a record of everything submitted
Save copies of the documents you provide, upload confirmations and written correspondence.
If you discuss an important issue by phone, follow up in writing to confirm your understanding.
Ask questions before the audit is finalized
If the auditor identifies a classification change, subcontractor charge or significant payroll difference, ask for an explanation and an opportunity to provide relevant records.
Not every auditor will provide preliminary findings, but asking about unresolved issues before the audit closes can help avoid confusion later.
What Happens If You Don’t Respond to a Workers’ Comp Audit?
Ignoring an audit can create problems beyond an additional premium bill.
California law provides insurers with specific remedies when policyholders fail to cooperate with required payroll reporting or audits.
Your insurance coverage may be affected
Under California Insurance Code §676.8, an insurer may cancel a workers’ compensation policy for certain failures involving payroll reporting, premium audits or payment of additional premium.
The statute provides for 10 days’ written notice in the circumstances it addresses, along with an opportunity to remedy the issue to the insurer’s satisfaction.
This can matter even when the audit concerns an expired policy.
In the published 2026 appellate decision Employers Preferred Insurance Co. v. Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board, 122 Cal.App.5th 467, the court upheld a cancellation arising from an employer’s failure to respond to audit requests relating to an earlier policy.
The employer’s subsequent coverage was at issue after a workplace injury.
The case illustrates why an audit request should not be ignored simply because the original policy has expired.
Failure to cooperate can also have substantial financial consequences
California Insurance Code §11760.1 provides a statutory consequence for certain failures to give an insurer access to records needed for a premium audit.
When the statute’s conditions are satisfied—including a third request for access over a period of at least 90 days and the absence of a compelling business reason—the employer may be assessed a total premium equal to three times the insurer’s estimated annual premium, plus the insurer’s costs of attempting the audit.
If the employer subsequently provides access and the audit is completed, the premium is revised to reflect the actual audit results.
This is not a charge automatically imposed whenever a contractor misses a single email or deadline. The statutory conditions matter.
Respond promptly and cooperate with reasonable audit requests to reduce the risk of these consequences.
If you cannot provide something requested, communicate with the auditor or insurer rather than remaining silent.
What Happens After You Submit Your Records?
Once the audit is completed, the insurance company calculates the final premium based on the audited information and applicable policy terms.
You should receive an audit statement, premium adjustment or related billing information.
Review three things.
1. The audited payroll and classifications
Compare the figures used by the auditor with your supporting records.
If something doesn’t match, identify the specific difference and ask for an explanation.
2. The final premium versus the balance due
These are not the same number.
The final premium represents the policy’s cost after the audit.
The balance due reflects what remains after applicable payments and credits.
A large balance doesn’t automatically mean the audit calculation is wrong.
3. Your audit records
Keep the final audit, supporting documents, submission confirmations and correspondence together.
You’ll need them if questions arise later, and they can make the next audit easier.
What if the audit bill is much higher than expected?
That’s a separate question—and an important one.
Our guide, Why Is My Workers’ Comp Audit So High?, walks through six areas to investigate, including payroll differences, classification changes, dual-wage records, subcontractor charges and overtime adjustments.
It also includes a reconciliation example and audit review worksheet.
If you believe an audit is incorrect, request the supporting details promptly and follow the applicable review or dispute procedures. Don’t assume that an informal question suspends billing obligations or preserves formal deadlines.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does receiving an audit notice mean I’m being investigated?
No. A routine workers’ compensation premium audit is a normal part of insurance administration. Receiving the notice alone doesn’t establish that the insurer suspects wrongdoing.
Can a physical workers’ comp audit be conducted remotely?
Yes. A physical audit generally involves examining original records and doesn’t necessarily require an in-person visit. California C-39 roofing contractors are subject to a separate statutory in-person visit requirement.
Do I still need to complete the audit if I cancelled my policy or switched carriers?
Generally, yes. Ending the policy doesn’t eliminate the insurer’s right to audit the exposure during the period it provided coverage.
Can I receive money back after a workers’ comp audit?
Yes. Depending on the audited exposure, premiums already paid and applicable policy terms, an audit can result in a return premium.
Why am I being audited if my roofing company has no employees?
California has special workers’ compensation insurance and audit requirements for C-39 roofing contractors. A roofing contractor’s claim that it has no employees doesn’t automatically eliminate those requirements.
Can I dispute a workers’ comp audit?
Yes. You can question audit findings and pursue applicable review or dispute procedures. The appropriate process depends on the issue, policy and governing California requirements. Act promptly and preserve relevant deadlines.
Free Guide: California Contractor’s Workers’ Comp Audit Readiness Guide
Preparing for an audit is easier when your records are organized before the auditor asks for them.
Unique Risk’s free Workers’ Comp Audit Readiness Guide includes a more detailed document checklist, explanations of common California contractor audit issues, subcontractor documentation guidance and job-cost tracking worksheets.
WC Audit Readiness Guide
The Bottom Line
Receiving a workers’ comp audit notice doesn’t mean something is wrong.
But it does mean you have a responsibility to respond.
Confirm the policy period and deadline, gather the requested records, describe your operations accurately and keep copies of everything you provide.
The objective isn’t to make your payroll look smaller. It’s to make sure the insurance company has accurate information to calculate your final premium.
Unique Risk Management and Insurance Services has specialized in commercial insurance for contractors and trades since 2007.
Scott Henricks is the founder of Unique Risk Management and Insurance Services, a commercial insurance brokerage specializing in California contractors and trades. He has been in the commercial insurance industry since 2003. Unique Risk is licensed in California, Colorado, Florida, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, Texas, and Utah. 949.305.5577 (Mission Viejo, CA) · 772.254.9221 (Port St. Lucie, FL) · scott@uniquerisk.com · CA Lic #0F56527
This article is for general educational purposes and does not constitute legal, tax or accounting advice. Audit requirements, classification rules and premium calculations depend on the applicable policy and governing rules.